Imagine waking up to darkness, eyes open, surrounded by stillness, musty air, and suffocating closeness. Sound? None, but breath and the rustle of silken fabric. You can’t move your arms or legs. Restrained? Lack of room? Dead? Maybe that’s it. My arms and legs are dead. Or I’m dead? Maybe. No, I’m dreaming. That’s it. Maybe I’m dreaming. Emotions swell, but panic is oddly absent. Just as oddly, strangely, you feel safe—safe but not free. Trapped, still a prisoner of this something you can’t quite grasp. “It’s a dream,” you think. That has to be it. Yet it’s far too real to be unreal. Or is it too unreal to be real? Yet, it IS real, and now you realize, “This is MY LIFE; this is MY REALITY.”You can handle this, you say to yourself. Five years in prison, now five years of probation for good behavior in prison. You’ve done nothing illegal, bad, awful, disgusting, or harmful to another person during five dark years of probation. You’ve done everything they asked you to do, hoping to escape the darkness that restricts, constricts, limits, and threatens to emotionally suffocate you. But somehow they find a way to suck you back into their stultifying darkness. “You didn’t do this right. You didn’t do that right. No, you didn’t commit a crime, you just didn’t think the way we want you to think, act the way we want you to act, suffer as much as we think you should suffer.”You may not have had a nightmare like this. Still, most of us have experienced some level of oppressive hopelessness, surrounded by the impossibility of escape, until we finally wake to the light of freedom shining on our faces. Whatever your nightmare, imagine spending the rest of your life trapped in that nightmare, never waking to life-giving light. A nightmare trapped in a coffin that you are shoved back into with the top slammed shut on you again and again. That’s what it is like to be a convicted sex offender: endless, circuitous punishment that ostracizes, marginalizes, and dehumanizes.After a convicted sex offender serves his prison time, he must then endure probation with quarterly polygraph examinations laced with questions that make it impossible not to tell the truth about obeying a multitude of laws and punitive restrictions cobbled together over many years by moralistic legislators and vindictive psychological professionals determined to “fix,” not heal. He must attend monthly psychological counseling that he must pay for after having lost his job because he was in prison, as well as now being unable to gain employment because of his criminal record. The offender must also attend group “therapy” sessions (which he must also pay for), of mostly men led by a woman of meager social work credentials who makes no secret about how deeply she abhors his very being as a convicted sex offender. He must sit there session after session as the counselor works to convince him that he is virtually the scum of the earth and needs to admit it to himself over and over until he begins to believe about himself what she believes about him. He sinks into depression as the counselor gaslights him and melds his personhood with his crime, until he and his crime are one, and he is no longer Joe who committed a sex offense but is now the crime incarnate. He can do nothing about the relentless degradation of his personhood but return to the suffocating darkness of the nightmare that never ends. Even if the offense is one of a lesser nature, the medieval nature of probation ultimately leaves the offender emotionally scarred by the system designed only to punish through deprivation, exclusion, and humiliation by psychologists, vindictive probation officers, and insufficiently trained counselors devoid of empathy and desire to heal.Surely, in the name of emotional justice, we can find a better way to vindicate the victim without emotionally destroying the offender.